Beer packaging is a crucial factor that impacts product quality, consumer perception, and business operations in the brewing industry. With growing attention to sustainability and experience, choosing between plastic and stainless steel packaging like reusable beer bottles has become a complex decision for beer brands. This article will analyze the key considerations, weighing the advantages and disadvantages of each material.
Plastic packaging provides lightweight, cost-effective options but faces backlash given environmental concerns. Stainless steel kegs boast superior durability and product integrity but come at a higher price point. By examining factors from production processes and recyclability to branding implications, breweries can make an informed choice when selecting packaging materials. As brewing industry trends increasingly prioritize sustainability, reusable stainless steel kegs stand out as an environmentally-friendly option to reduce waste.
Stainless steel provides a durable, inert, and sustainable packaging option, though higher associated costs limit its adoption. Stainless steel gets its corrosion resistance and strength from the addition of chromium, with other alloying elements like nickel to optimize properties.
The beer industry mostly uses stainless steel in kegs and growlers. Stainless steel kegs have been used for decades since they can withstand the rigors of transportation, retain pressure, and don't affect taste. Stainless steel growlers and kegs are growing as consumer-level sustainable packaging.
Stainless steel is naturally impervious to oxygen, light exposure, and leaching compared to plastic. This helps maintain optimum beer quality, flavor stability, and extended shelf life. The materials' rigidity also adds a perception of quality and premiums. Many consumers feel stainless steel kegs improve the drinking experience compared to plastic or glass.
However, stainless steel packaging comes at a price premium, typically 4-5 times higher per unit than plastic. Stainless steel fabrication also requires high energy consumption and specialized equipment for shaping and welding, increasing the environmental footprint. While infinitely recyclable, stainless steel recycling rates remain low at around 70% , though there are few current initiatives to improve this.
Plastic is the most ubiquitous packaging material used for beer today. The two main types of plastic used are polyethylene terephthalate (PET) and high-density polyethylene (HDPE). In 2019, plastic accounted for over 95% of the primary packaging market share for beer globally, with Asia and South America relying almost exclusively on plastic bottles and cans.
PET is commonly used for transparent and semi-transparent beer bottles, prized for its lightweight strength and ability to hold carbonation. HDPE is favored for opaque beer bottles and cans due to its density and barrier properties.
However, plastic is increasingly scrutinized for its environmental impacts. Most plastic beer packaging is designed for single-use consumption, leading to waste and pollution issues if not properly recycled. Recycling rates for plastics are already low on average, and plastic waste in the oceans continues to grow annually. There are also concerns that plastic may leach chemicals into beer over time, compromising flavor and safety.
Plastic production emits greenhouse gasses, and post-consumer plastic waste is a mounting ecological issue. In the US alone, over 3 million tons of plastic waste from beverage containers end up in landfills each year. Only around 28% of that plastic is recycled; the rest takes over 400 years to decompose if left untreated in landfills.
Ocean pollution is also a major problem, with around 8 million metric tons of plastic entering the oceans annually. This hurts marine ecosystems and can even impact human health via contaminated seafood supply chains. Most beer brands rely heavily on plastic rings, multi-pack wrapping, and secondary packaging which exacerbates these issues.
While stainless steel has an environmental footprint, its durability, recyclability, and inertness provide sustainability advantages over plastic. The production of virgin stainless steel requires mining iron ore and metal alloys, demanding substantial energy. However, once formed, steel products can be reused for decades and re-melted infinitely without degradation. As the brewing industry trends toward sustainability, stainless steel offers a durable and reusable option compared to single-use plastics.
Optimizing manufacturing processes and alloy compositions can reduce stainless steel's carbon emissions by up to 64% . Coatings have also been developed to improve its scratch resistance to boost lifecycle reuse potential. Though life cycle assessments vary, most conclude stainless steel ultimately compares favorably to plastics in eco-impact.
Global beer packaging regulations continue to evolve, imposing new criteria for materials, safety, recycling, and energy use. In the US, the FDA regulates food-grade packaging materials, ensuring plastics and coatings used do not leach harmful chemicals when exposed to beer over time. California's Prop 65 also limits heavy metals in packaging, including lead which can contaminate stainless steel alloys.
The EU has more stringent regulations, pushing for improved recycling under its Circular Economy Package which sets targets of 90% reuse of steel packaging by 2030. Regulations on single-use plastics are also growing, including bans on plastic rings. Energy efficiency is another consideration, as stainless steel production is greenhouse gas intensive. Carbon taxes and cap-and-trade schemes are increasing materials costs.
Navigating this complex regulatory environment will require agility and strategic planning from beer brands. Investing in sustainable packaging and energy-efficient manufacturing will foster regulatory compliance and resonate with environmentally-conscious consumers.
Sustainability has risen to the forefront of packaging innovation and adoption trends in the beer industry. Securing public trust through eco-friendly materials and practices is now a competitive advantage. Leaders aim to minimize packaging weight, source renewable inputs, and facilitate recycling.
Bioplastics using plant-based resins offer an alternative to reduce fossil fuel reliance but need more R&D to match conventional polymer properties. Various companies are rolling out plastic-free can carrier rings and shrink wraps made of cardboard.
Stainless steel beer kegs, when properly maintained, can be reused for over a decade. Their durability and cleanability support a circular lifecycle model that reduces waste versus single-use packaging. With routine cleaning, stainless steel kegs provide a sustainable option for beverage delivery and storage.
Breweries like Sierra Nevada and New Belgium have transitioned to using stainless steel kegs and have seen benefits like cost savings and improved efficiency. Reusable stainless steel kegs can reduce greenhouse gas emissions by 47% and waste by 95% compared to single-use kegs. For example, Sierra Nevada's switch to stainless steel is estimated to save approximately 8.3 million pounds of CO2 emissions per year . By opting for durable, recyclable materials, breweries can reduce their environmental footprint while supporting circular economic principles.
Make the Sustainable Choice with INOXCVA
At INOXCVA, we offer premium stainless steel kegs and draught solutions designed for sustainability. Experience the difference between our durable, inert steel kegs that maintain beer freshness and quality. Reduce your packaging waste and carbon footprint. Request a quote today to upgrade your draught packaging to eco-friendly stainless steel.
With INOXCVA, you can demonstrate your commitment to the environment while showcasing quality and building customer loyalty. Join the sustainability leaders choosing stainless steel.
Help Us to Prepare for a Sustainable Future!